Kellogg PhD Fellow Stefanie Israel (sociology) has been awarded a Social Science Research Council International Dissertation Research Fellowship (SSRC–IDRF) to support her comparative ethnography of four “pacified” favelas in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Earlier this year, she was awarded a Fulbright Study-Research Grant for the same project.
The prestigious funding will allow her to spend the entire calendar year of 2016 conducting research in Rio. She will observe urban reform efforts in favela communities at a key point in time: before, during, and after the 2016 Summer Olympic Games, which have been a focus of protests sweeping across Brazil.
“I am delighted to hear that Stefanie has received both the SSRC and Fulbright awards, ” says Faculty Fellow Ann Mische, the chair of Israel’s dissertation committee, who knows firsthand how competitive the selection processes are from her previous experience on the SSRC–IDRF selection committee.
“For the SSRC dissertation fellowship, there are usually more than 1000 applications for 80 slots. It is wonderful that Stefanie has achieved this kind of success—but I am not surprised.”
“Stefanie is an exceptionally focused, mature, and sophisticated young scholar, with a compelling research project on an issue of urgent social concern. She is poised to make an important contribution to scholarship and policy on urban violence, police reform, and community change, in addition to shedding light on a quick-moving situation in Brazil.”
“The police pacification program aims to regain control of areas previously dominated by armed drug traffickers,” says Israel. “It also represents a new approach to policing the favelas, a move from violent ‘siege-style’ police operations to ‘proximity policing.’”
The research has policy implications for countries that see the program as a possible model for future efforts to quell criminal domination of poor communities. It also promises to be helpful to Brazil, providing a more in-depth evaluation of the program than that captured so far by interview-based studies or often-suspect reported crime data.
“The research is of direct relevance to the over one million residents of Rio who live in favelas,” Israel says. She will investigate how the program plays out on the ground: studying the contributions of local networks and community mediation to pacification, evaluating why it succeeds in some communities and fails in others, and identifying mechanisms that work to build trust between police and residents.
“Rio’s favela pacification program provides a unique opportunity to study what Kellogg founder Guillermo O’Donnell called ‘brown areas’ in transition,” Israel says. She explains that brown areas refer to territories within a democratic state where the formal rule of law is weak and private actors, such as mafia-like groups, enforce an efficient but violent form of “justice.”
“Ethnographic research requires extensive time in the field in order to build trust with residents and to grasp the complexity of the situation,” she adds. The Fulbright and SSRC grants will give her the luxury of an extended period in the favelas to follow up on work begun during three summer research trips.
In Brazil, Israel will be working with her Fulbright affiliate, Alba Zaluar of the Institute of Social and Political Studies at the State University of Rio de Janeiro (IESP-UERJ), perhaps the leading expert on Rio’s favelas. Israel met Zaluar during a preliminary research trip last summer funded by a Graduate Research Grant.
“I am deeply grateful for the many ways Kellogg has supported me—and continues to support me—during my time at Notre Dame,” says Israel. “My applications for funding would not have been nearly as competitive without Kellogg's support.”
Israel is the recipient of a 2011–16 Kellogg Institute PhD Fellowship, in addition to last year’s research grant.